How to decide between a coloured gemstone or a diamond engagement ring


18ct White Gold, Fancy Diamond Ring

18ct White Gold, Fancy Diamond Ring

In the enchanting journey towards matrimony, one of the most significant milestones is the selection of an engagement ring. This choice, often a delicate balance between tradition and personal taste, largely revolves around a central question: should you choose a diamond or a coloured gemstone? This decision is not just about aesthetics; it's a reflection of your story, values, and the unique bond you share with your partner. Diamonds, with their timeless allure, have long been the go-to choice for couples seeking a symbol of everlasting love. Yet, in recent times, coloured gemstones have surged in popularity, offering a canvas of colours each imbued with deep symbolism and an opportunity for individual expression. In this guide, we'll explore the beauty and significance of both options, helping you navigate this sparkling sea of choices with confidence and clarity, ensuring that the ring you choose not only dazzles but also resonates with your personal love narrative. 


The Timeless Elegance of Diamonds


Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring

Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring

Historical Significance and Symbolism

Diamonds have captivated the human imagination for centuries, evolving into symbols of enduring love and commitment in the context of engagement rings. This tradition finds its origins in the 15th century, when Archduke Maximilian of Austria commissioned a diamond ring for his betrothal to Mary of Burgundy. This historic event marked the beginning of diamonds being synonymous with engagements, a trend that gained momentum among European aristocracy.

The significance of diamonds in engagement rings is deeply rooted in their perceived rarity and indestructibility. In ancient times, diamonds were believed to be tears of the gods or splinters from falling stars, imbuing them with a mystical and divine quality. This connection to the heavens suggested an otherworldly bond, making diamonds a fitting symbol for a union that was meant to last a lifetime.

Over the centuries, as diamond cutting and shaping techniques evolved, so did the symbolism associated with these precious stones. They came to represent not only unbreakable bonds but also purity, owing to their clear, unblemished appearance. The clarity of a diamond was seen as a mirror to the depth and honesty of the commitment between two individuals.

In the Victorian and Edwardian eras, diamonds became more accessible to the broader public, further cementing their status in engagement traditions. The discovery of diamond mines in South Africa in the late 19th century played a pivotal role in this transition, making diamonds more available and subsequently more popular as symbols of betrothal.

Unrivalled Durability and Brilliance

The durability of a diamond is unmatched. Ranking highest on the Mohs scale of mineral hardness, diamonds are incredibly resistant to scratches and abrasions, making them an ideal choice for everyday wear. This resilience also makes a diamond ring a lasting heirloom, capable of being passed down through generations. In addition to their hardness, diamonds are renowned for their exceptional brilliance. The way a diamond is cut and polished allows it to capture light and create a spectacular display of sparkle, symbolising the bright future of the couple.

Versatility in Design

Diamonds offer unparalleled versatility in terms of design and style. Whether set in a simple solitaire or a complex, multi-stone arrangement, diamonds adapt to all designs with elegance. Their colourless nature allows them to blend seamlessly with any metal - be it classic gold, modern platinum, or the warm hues of rose gold. This versatility extends to complementing any personal style, from the minimalist who appreciates sleek lines to the romantic who adores vintage charm.

Customization and Quality Factors

When selecting a diamond, there are various factors to consider - the most well-known being the "Four Cs": Cut, Colour, Clarity, and Carat weight. These criteria not only determine the quality and value of the diamond but also allow for a level of customization in choosing a ring that aligns with personal preferences and budget. A well-cut diamond, even of a smaller size, can have a brilliance that outshines a larger stone of lesser quality, providing options for all tastes and budgets. 


Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring

Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring


The Alluring Charm of Coloured Gemstones

Variety and Personalization

Coloured gemstones bring a world of colour and meaning to the realm of engagement rings. Each gemstone carries its own unique hue and story, offering a wide range of options to match any personality. For example, a sapphire doesn't just come in the classic royal blue; it can be found in pinks, yellows, and even whites. This variety allows for a level of personalization that diamonds can't quite match. When you choose a coloured gemstone, you're not just selecting a piece of jewellery; you're making a statement about individuality and preference.

Symbolism and Significance

Coloured gemstones in engagement rings are not just about visual appeal; they carry deep symbolism and historical significance that can add layers of meaning to this special commitment. Each type of gemstone has its own unique story, resonating with different attributes and emotions, which makes the choice both personal and symbolic.


Diamond Halo Sapphire Engagement Ring

Diamond Halo Sapphire Engagement Ring

Sapphires: Traditionally, sapphires symbolise nobility, truth, and sincerity, making them an ideal choice for an engagement ring. Their association with loyalty and fidelity dates back to ancient times and continues to make them a popular choice for couples looking to imbue their rings with these enduring qualities. The versatility of sapphires in colour also allows for personalization while maintaining their symbolic importance.


Flowering Emerald and Diamond Engagement Ring

Flowering Emerald and Diamond Engagement Ring

Emeralds: Emeralds are celebrated for their rich green hue, which is often associated with new beginnings, growth, and renewal. This makes them an apt symbol for an engagement, marking the start of a new life together. Historically, emeralds were believed to bring harmony, wisdom, and love to the wearer, adding a deeper level of significance to the choice of this gemstone for an engagement ring.


Cushion Ruby and Diamond Ring

Cushion Ruby and Diamond Ring

Rubies: Known for their vibrant red colour, rubies symbolise passion, strength, and courage. They are often chosen by couples who wish to celebrate the intensity and depth of their love. In many cultures, rubies are considered the stone of the heart, signifying deep emotions and the unbridled enthusiasm of love.

Design and Style

The versatility of coloured gemstones in design is another aspect to consider. These stones can be the centrepiece in a variety of settings, from classic to contemporary, and they complement a wide range of metals, including gold, platinum, and rose gold. The colour of the gemstone can influence the ring's overall aesthetic, creating opportunities for unique and eye-catching designs. For those who favour a more vintage or eclectic look, coloured gemstones can be combined with smaller diamonds to create a piece that is both distinctive and timeless.

Budget Considerations

Coloured gemstones can also be more budget-friendly compared to diamonds. This often means you can opt for a larger stone or a more intricate setting for the same price. For couples looking to maximise their budget without compromising on the ring's impact, gemstones like amethyst, garnet, or topaz offer stunning beauty at a more accessible price point. However, it's important to note that some gemstones, like sapphire and ruby, can be on the higher end of the price spectrum due to their rarity and demand.


Considerations for Durability and Lifestyle

When selecting between a diamond and a coloured gemstone for an engagement ring, it's crucial to contemplate not only the beauty but also the practicality of the stone in relation to your partner's lifestyle. Diamonds are renowned for their hardness, ranking highest on the Mohs scale, making them remarkably resistant to scratches and daily wear. This makes them an ideal choice for someone with an active lifestyle or a hands-on profession.

On the other hand, coloured gemstones, while offering a vibrant and unique appeal, vary greatly in their hardness and durability. Sapphires and rubies are excellent choices for those seeking colour but also needing durability, as they are next to diamonds in hardness. These stones can withstand daily wear well, making them suitable for most lifestyles.

However, some gemstones like opals, pearls, or emeralds are softer and more prone to scratches, chips, and damage. These stones require more mindful care and are better suited for individuals with a less active lifestyle or those who plan to wear their ring on special occasions rather than daily.

Another aspect to consider is maintenance. While diamonds generally require minimal upkeep to keep their sparkle, some coloured gemstones may need regular care, specific cleaning methods, or even professional maintenance to preserve their colour and lustre.

The setting of the ring also plays a significant role in the durability of the stone. A protective setting, like a bezel setting, can shield a softer gemstone from knocks and bumps. In contrast, more exposed settings, while beautiful, might not be the best choice for softer stones if the ring is worn every day.


Making a Personal Statement

Selecting an engagement ring is a deeply personal affair, a tangible symbol of your unique love story and the journey you are about to embark on together. This is where the distinction between a diamond and a coloured gemstone becomes more than just a matter of aesthetics; it's about making a personal statement.

Coloured gemstones open a world of creativity and individual expression. They break away from tradition, offering a modern twist on engagement rings. Each stone carries its own history and symbolism - a blue sapphire might echo the depth and sincerity of your partner's eyes, a vibrant ruby could symbolise the fiery passion of your relationship, or a serene emerald might reflect a shared love for nature. The choice of a coloured gemstone can be a nod to personal stories, significant moments, or even shared values.

Diamonds, in contrast, offer a classic and timeless elegance. They speak of tradition, durability, and the unchanging nature of true love. A diamond ring can be a link to the past, connecting generations through family heirlooms, or it can symbolise a hopeful and steadfast future. For those who value tradition, the purity and brilliance of a diamond can be the ultimate expression of enduring love.

In the end, the decision is not just about picking a stone. It's about what resonates with your partner's personality, tastes, and the narrative you both share. Whether it's the classic elegance of a diamond or the unique character of a coloured gemstone, the choice should reflect the essence of your relationship. It's about finding that perfect piece that resonates with the heart - a ring that not only adorns the finger but also tells a story, your story.

The choice between a diamond and a coloured gemstone engagement ring is deeply personal and reflective of individual taste, lifestyle, and the story you wish to tell. Whether you opt for the enduring brilliance of a diamond or the personalised touch of a coloured gemstone, the most important factor is the love and commitment it symbolises. In the end, the right ring is the one that makes your heart sing - a perfect symbol of your journey together.


A wonderful vintage Toi et Moi ring, which combines a diamond and a coloured gemstone

Reddit / A wonderful vintage Toi et Moi ring, which combines a diamond and a coloured gemstone

In conclusion, deciding between a diamond and a coloured gemstone for an engagement ring is a journey that intertwines personal taste, lifestyle considerations, and the unique narrative of your relationship. Diamonds, with their timeless elegance and unrivalled durability, offer a classic choice that speaks of tradition and enduring love. Coloured gemstones, on the other hand, provide a canvas for personal expression, allowing you to infuse the ring with individuality, symbolism, and a splash of colour. Whether you choose the sparkling brilliance of a diamond or the vivid charm of a gemstone, the most important aspect is that the ring resonates with your personal love story and symbolises the commitment and love you share. Ultimately, the perfect engagement ring is one that captures the essence of your relationship and continues to inspire and reflect your journey together for years to come.


Featured / seasonal collection banner